Sales
Martin-Scott
Summer 2014
Article 3
Holder in Due Course
If have a holder + value, good faith and no-notice = holder in due course (HDC)
o 3-104 Negotiability (super 7)
§ Writing
§ Signed
· Present intent to authenticate
§ Unconditional promise (Note) OR Order (Check)
· 3-106 Unconditional unless
o Express condition to payment
o Promise/Order is subject to another writing
o Rights to the promise are stated in another writing
· Not a condition even if
· Rights to collateral, prepayment is referenced in another writing
· Payment is from another fund
o Co-signatures is not a condition
§ A fixed amount of money
· Can have interest
§ Carrier w/o luggage
· No added things
· If it is doubtful that the instrument is negotiable
o Presumed not the be negotiable
§ Payable on demand or at a definite time
§ Payable to bearer or to order
· 3-109 Must say either
o Bearer Paper
o Order Paper
o Negotiation- this is the transfer of the valid paper
§ Stages
· 3-105 Issuance
· 3-203 Transfer
o Every legal significant movement between issue and presentment
o Transfer vests in the transferee ALL the legal rights on the transferor
§ Presentment
o Endorsement
§ Order Paper
· A signature by a proper person (payee/transferee) AND delivery of the instrument to the transferee
· If the Payee wants to transfer
o Bank (Drawee) will require the payee’s signature
• Blank endorsement (Creates Bearer paper)
· Payee signs the back of the instrument
• Special endorsement (Keeps Order paper)
· Payee must specify a new payee by writing “Pay Name”
· Multiple endorsers requires AND Requires both signatures
o Or Requires either signature
o Must have multiple indorsers… to transfer it requires both signatures OR either signature
§ Bearer Paper
· Delivery of the instrument to the transferee
o Does not need an endorsement
§ Forgery
· Order paper
o Only the named payee can become a holder
o Payee must have possession and endorse the instrument
• For anyone to be considered a holder
o An unauthorized signature is not effective negotiation
• No later transferee can be a holder
o 3-302 Holder in Due Course (HDC)
§ Must have a holder (Negotiability and Negotiation)
· 3-303 Value
o Something given
• Performance on a promise
· Promise is not enough
• Cannot be court ordered
• Cannot be a gift
• Partial value = Partial HDC
o Moment that value is given
• Become a HDC (If other elements are met)
o Banks are typically not an HDC for checks deposited
• They don’t give value
· To the extent that they give you more than what you have value
• First in first out
· Money in the account first is taken out first
· Acted in Good faith
o Intertwined w/ no notice
o Subjective test
• Honesty in fact
o Objective test
• Observance of reasonable commercial standards of fair dealing
• Should have known
· No Notice
o Received the instrument w/o notice of
• Tampering
• Forgery
• Illegality
o Insolvency = notice
o Generally no duty to inquire about the note validity, unless something looks suspicious. If something looks suspicious, then inquiry may be needed.
• To be notice for this purpose the person must receive notice and a reasonable time to act
o 3-304 Notice of default
• Default on Interest payment
· No Notice
• Default on principle
· Notice
o For
· Maker
§ What type of lawsuit
· Conversion
· Breach of K/warranty
§ Defenses
· Can liability be passed off
o Bounced Check
§ Can sue
· On the check
· On the underlying transaction
o Underlying transaction
§ 3-310 Personal Check
· Suspends the obligation
o Until
• Check is dishonored
• Check is paid/certified
· Check is not an assignment of funds
o Until it is cashed
• 3-310 Certified Check
· Discharges the obligation
o Liability on the instrument
§ §3-412 Maker Liability
· Person who made the instrument
· Primary liability
· 3-316 More than one maker
o Joint and Several liability
• Maker can get contribution for proportional share
· If other maker is solvent
· §3-605 (f) Co-maker protection
o If bank fails to perfect their interest in collateral
• Discharges the Co-maker to the value of the collateral
• 3-415 Endorser liability
· Endorsers are liable to subsequent endorsers
· Ultimate liability
o First endorser
· Secondary liability
o In order to sue must have
• Presentment
• Dishonor
• Notice of dishonor
· Avoid liability
o Write “w/o recourse” next to your signature
· More than one endorser at one time
o Joint and several liability
o Can get contribution for proportional share
• If the other endorser is solvent
• Surety liability