Select Page

Capital Markets
University of Texas Law School
Spindler, James C.

 
Spindler_CapMarkets_Spring_2015
 
1/21/2015
Overview/PowerPoint slides
 
·         Shadow bank: non-bank institutions that don't take deposits.
o    Short-term liabilities and long-term assets
o    Got in trouble in 2008
·         Biggest bank failure was Washington Mutual (2008).
·         Mutual fund: Company like Vanguard that takes money from people saving for retirement, and mutual fund company buys stocks (pool of money used to buy other things).
o    Investment pool.
o    Under securities law, called investment companies and are heavily regulated.
o    Money-market mutual fund.
·         Broker/dealer requirements
o    Madoff was broker dealer, invested for the clients through mutual fund.
·         Ponzi scheme- taking new investment money to pay old investors as their ROI.
·         Market making activities
o    Securitization and derivatives
 
Unit 1 (Facebook Pre-IPO):
·         Securities offerings (every security offerings/sales is one of these 3 things):
o    Registered
o    Exempt
o    Illegal
·         1933 Act (Securities Act of 1933):
·         Why trade securities? Economics of liquidity
o    Creating liquidity in stock allows creation of public offering in your stock but that is not only way.
·         How to provide liquidity short of a registered offering (IPO)?
·         Evidence on welfare effects of these formal markets?
o    No evidence but that's because hard to study effects (sample size of 1- the whole market).
·         Three areas of regulation for securities transaction:
o    Issuance/Sale:
·         Issuer, like Facebook, selling shares to someone outside of FB (offer/sale).
·         Sophistication of the parties comes into play; Gordon Gekko playing with shares compared to uneducated people like farmers.
§   Information asymmetry- one party knows more than another one does.
·         Causes market to break down due to adverse selection. 
·         Heavily regulated (gekko to farmer transaction; but not so much farmer to farmer)
·         Primary sale
o    Trading middleman (broker/dealer)
·         Gekko trader to another Gekko trader with Morgan Stanley handling transaction.
§  Morgan stanley/similar middleman there to help supervise that no one lying etc. and makes transaction anonymous so no communication of info between ultimate buyer and seller.
·         Anonymizes transaction.
·         Would prefer that the middleman be neutral on the stock they are trading.
·         Firewalls exist to block the middleman employees working for that client stock and other ones that are supervising transactions in order to not have conflict of interest.
·          Middleman broker/dealer makes money from fees and from market making (covering spread).
§  Less need for regulation than first example, not as concerned with information asymmetry as long as neither has insider trading info.
§  Secondary sale (not directly from company, being traded among investors)
§  Can have price discovery problems, don't know what stock is worth and relying on money manager to know value AND thus need for regulation and basic rules for regulation are: need to be loyal to client and can't lie,  fiduciary role in putting interests of clients in front of their own (investment advisors for people; if between Gekkos does not really matter).
o    Investment pools and advice
·         General rule for providing investment advice (investors giving money to Zoom LLC that then buys FB stock for them), required to disclose how much intermediary paid for the stock.
·         This category is kind of a subset of 1 and 2 (issuance/sale & trading middlemen).
·         Intermediary between primary/secondary sale.
 
1/26/2015
 
1933 Act
 
·         No trade theorem- when you realize one party wants to trade with you, they know something you don't and thus should not trade so never trade.
·         Three types of offerings:
o    Registered: IPO or Seasoned offering (public offering) and filings with SEC, after this you are public company and have quarterly and annual filings with SEC.
o    Exempt:
·         4(2) private placement
§  Rule 506: Accredited investors
·         Safe harbor of 4(2)
·         This is what hedge funds use, and selling to rich people (people making over 300k, and have over one million net worth).
§  Reg S: Offshore exemption
§  Rule 144A:
·         Safe harbor of 4(2).
·         Resale of qualified institutional buyers rule, for very liquid markets.
·         Insurance and banks
·         If starting company and selling stock to angel investors; sale of security?
§  Probably
·         If you run company as partnership and take on money investor (you and partners do), is that a sale of securities
§  Yes, anything can be a security (anytime you are raising money in any sort of company, can be considered to a security probably). Can be partnership, unincorporated entity.
o    If not exempt or registered, then illegal:
·         If do it intentional, can go to jail.
·         If unintentional, buyer of securities has right of rescission against you and unwind the sale and this is at their option; if things go well, they don't have to do so but if it goes bad they give back to you for price they paid for.
§  This is if you made illegal offering.
·          How was FB able to sell stock to employees, founders and venture capitalists without having to file registration statement?
o    Private placement, exempt category:
o    4(a)(2)- Section 5 of Act don't apply to transactions by an issuer not involving any public offering- aka they are all private offerings.
·         Employees, founders etc are all private sales.
·         Can't go put in an ad in wall street journal seeking investors (this is for registered offer of securities going through SEC, but it is not exempt deal).
·         What makes something private?
§  If the offer is limited to people who are sophisticated and informed, that counts as a non-public offering of securities.
§  Qualify for 4(a)(2) by offering only to sophisticated and informed; and these are employees and informed venture capital. Can make them informed

e and betting against you.
·         So why do people trade anytime, how is trading possible given asymmetric information?
·         A noise trading model is a possibility.
·         Disclosure games and asymmetric information
·         Take expected value of statistics you have. Ex: Unopened Fedex box, don't know value so how much do you bid?
·         20% chance it has 1k; 50% chance it has $200; 30% chance it has nothing, so expected value is 300 and bid 300 or below.
·         Now, box opened by seller prior to you bidding so seller knows what's in the box:
·         So if seller accepts your bid of 300, it can only be the $200 amount or $0 since seller would keep the 1k value if that is what it was.
·         So bid lower now, below 200 and since possibility other than 200 is getting 0, bid strictly less than 200.
·         THIS is adverse selection example for asymmetric information that only the worst thing gets sold.
·         And game because how much would you be willing to pay and what would the seller be willing to sell?
·         Need to force OBAMAcare because insurance adverse selection, young people would never pay for insurance etc, need to pay.
·         Credible disclosure allows sales transactions to take place:
·         Have trusted sellers
·         Repeat play/business helps relationship.
·         Reputation: 1) Good personality, and 2) what's in it for me to behave this time/ getting future business.
·         Have trusted intermediaries to look in the box (and look at audit of companies).
·         h
·         Anti-fraud rules
·         Fine of 300 bucks with perfect enforcement and judicial administrability and works only in some cases since the fine is too low (for something that is worth 1k).
·         If it's too high, is that ok? If perfectly administered
·         Now if fine is 8k, but 10% chance that could be wrong. Expected value to seller of selling gold is 90% (1000) – 10% (8000)=100. Expected value of selling Britney is 90%(200)-10%(8000)=-620
·         So only a gold sale is possible here.
·         So if fine is very high with chance of small positive, it chills beneficial behavior (can't sell Britney spears) and can deter small companies or deter other activities since never know for sure that price will stay up etc, could go down.
·         Limitations occur if justice system does not work as well as you would like And a fine that is too low or high can deter transactions.Â