Select Page

Tax
University of Kentucky School of Law
Westin, Richard A.

Chapter 1- Introduction & Key Concepts
 
Basic Tax Formula
 
Income from all sources
Less: exclusions
Gross Income
Less: For AGI deductions
Adjusted Gross Income
Less: Greater of Standard Deduction or Itemized Deductions
Less: Personal Exemptions
Taxable Income
 
–          exclusions: not included on the tax return- this includes things like gifts, child support, interest on state bonds
–          gross income: this is the first number included on the tax return; this would include items like income, dividends, business income, etc…
–          for AGI deductions: these are deductions that everyone gets to take; includes things like business expenses, interest expense for student loans, etc…; also referred to as above the line deductions
–          standard deduction: every tp is entitled to this; the amount is set by Congress; this amount of money is deducted from gross income and is therefore not taxed; people who itemize cannot use this deduction
–          personal exemptions: each tp is entitled to one; ex. a family that consists of a mother, father and 2 dependent children get to take 4 personal exemptions on their tax return
–          taxable income: this is the amount that is multiplied by the tax rate to determine how much is owed or refunded
 
Where does tax law come from?
–          internal revenue code: highest legislative authority
–          treasury regulations: interpretations of the tax code by Treasury Dept.; legislative regs have a higher authority than interpretative regs
–          IRS rulings: issued by IRS to interpret law, do not have same authority as treasury regs; include letter rulings, rev procs, technical advice memos
–          Case law: note- a trial ct must abide by the precedents set by the ct of appeals in that jurisdiction
 
Type of tax system:
–          the individual income tax is a progressive system
–          this means that as taxable income rises, the rate of tax on the next increment of taxable income increases
 
Tax Procedure and Administration
–          all tax returns are initially checked for mathematical accuracy & items that are clearly erroneous
–          Selection for Audits: the IRS uses a computer program to classify returns that are selected for audit
–          Types of Audits:
o       Office audit: individual is asked to substantiate a particular deduction, credit or income item
o       Field audit: often used for corps; conducted at the tp’s place of business
–          Statute of Limitations:
o       Generally the SOL runs 3 years from the later of the date the return was filed or its due date
o       SOL is 6 years if the tp omits items of gross income > 25% of gross income reported on the return
o       SOL never runs if a fraudulent return is filed OR if no return is filed
–          Audit Procedure:
o       After the audit, the IRS will issue a 30-day letter- allows the tp 30 days to appeal to the administrative appeal officer
o       If tp does nothing, IRS will then issue a 90-day letter- this gives tp 90 days to appeal the tax deficiency to the tax court
o       if you don’t appeal to tax court in 90 days à your option is to pay the tax deficiency, file for a refund with the IRS; IRS will reject that; then you can sue in Federal Dist Ct or the US Federal Ct of Claims based on the wrongful rejection of your refund request
 
Primary Tax PolicyConcepts
–          tax policy: body of norms used to evaluate and shape tax legislation and administration
–          Revenues: the tax must be adequate as a revenue source
–          Taxes should be fair- the burden of the tax should be offset by the benefits received from the tax
Vertical equity: notion of imposing proportionately or progressively higher taxes on those with greater incomes on the theory that they have a greater ability to pay and the sacrifice of paying taxes is less
Horizontal equity: people who are in similar economic situations should pay the same amt of taxes and benefit from equivalent tax breaks
–          Tax should be certain, convenient and economical to collect
–          Tax rules should be clear (transparent)
–          Tax should be free of interpretive doubt and have obvious meanings and purposes
–          Should be compatible with a free mkt
not play a role in the decision-making of individuals
–          Should be consistent with macroeconomic values
Tax shouldn’t stimulate inflation or invite a recession
 
 
 
Chapter 2- Gross Income
 
Concept of Income
–          Haig-Simons definition of income:
Consumption + Increase in net worth = Gross income
This is the most commonly used economists’ definition of gross income
–          Tax concept of income: In general there must be 3 conditions met for amounts to be taxable
Must be an economic benefit
Income must be realized
Generally this occurs when the earning process is complete and a transaction with another party takes place that permits an objective measure of income
Income must be recognized
** The IRS also takes into consideration the idea of administrative convenience when determining what is gross income.
 
–          §61(a) provides the general definition of gross income:
o       gross income means all income (unless otherwise excluded) from whatever source derived, including (but not limited to) these times: compensation for services, business income, gains from dealings in property, interest, rents, royalties, dividends, alimony, annuities, income from life insurance, pensions, income from discharge of indebtedness, distributive share of p/s gross income, ird
–          in general, if a tp benefits from an item, it is taxable
 
Interpreting the Tax Code
–          Reenactment doctrine: when a code section is reenacted, the judicial and administrative interpretations of the section were implicitly incorporated in the new law
–          Statutory Construction:
o       Textualist: objective; limited to what an ordinary person could reasonably understand the text of a statute to mean at the time it was enacted; only look to legislative history as a last resort
o       Intentionalist: more subjective; consider legislative history
o       Purposivist: most subjective; try to discern the purpose from an overall reading of the statute or from legislative history
 
Concept of Basis & Return of Capital
–          basis: this is the owner’s tax investment
o       the purpose of identifying the basis is that when a sale/exchange occurs, you are only taxed on the income- that is the amount in excess of your basis
–          Example: You buy something for $100,000. Later, you sell it for $150,000.
o       The basis is $100,000.
o       Your income on the sale is $50,000- that is the amount you are taxed on
§         The other portion of the sell price is considered a return of capital and is not taxed
–          Misc. Ideas Concerning Basis:
o       Reg. 1.61-2(d): if you are paid in king à the value of the property received is gross income
§         Also, the fmv of the property received for services becomes its basis
o       §1012: the basis of property is generally its cost
 
 
Misc. Stuff about Gross Income
–          income from illegal sources is taxable
–          Treasure trove: finder has gross income to the extent of its value in the tax year where it is undisputed that it is in your possession
–          TP may have income as a result of reducing its perso

ely very difficult to figure out what the decedent’s cost was after they have died
o       Valuation date is either
§         Date of death; or
§         Alternative valuation date- which is 6 months after death
o       Note that the inheritance is free of income taxes
o       Example: TP inherits property with an $80,000 fmv on the date of the decedent’s death. The decedent’s basis is $47,000.
§         TP’s basis = $80,000
–          Basis of Property received as a Gift
o       The donee of a gift takes the same basis in the property that the donor had
o       If the donee sells the gift property at a loss à the basis in the property is the LOWER of
§         the donor’s basis
§         the value of the property when give to the donee
o       Also note that the donee of property does NOT have any gross income on receipt of the gift AND the donor does not realize any gain or loss on making the gift.
o       Example: Chuck makes a gift of property with a basis of $600 to Maggie when the property has a $500 fmv. 
§         If property sold at a GAIN à (more than $500) basis = $600
§         If property sold at a LOSS (less than $500)à basis = $500
§         If property sold for $500 or more, but not more than $600 à no gain or loss is recognized
o       The purpose of this last rule is to prevent tax-avoidance schemes where you shift unrealized losses to another tp by making gifts of the loss property. 
–          Basis when Property is Exchanged for Property
o       When property is exchanged for property, the tp is taxed on the difference between the adjusted basis of the property given in exchange and the fmv of the property received in exchange.
 
Apportioning/Allocating Basis
–          Based on Spatial Components
o       If a tp buys a parcel of land and then he subdivides it à he must apportion the basis of the overall property among the parcels to be sold in order to determine the gain or loss upon the sale of each parcel
o       Problem 3-9
o       Common costs incurred to obtain or prepare an asset for service must be capitalized and allocated to the basis of the individual assets
o       Example: TP acquires 3 machines for $60,000, which have fmvs of $30,000, 20,000 and 10,000 respectively. Costs of delivery amount to $2,000 and costs to install the 3 machines amount to $1,000. 
§         The total installation and delivery costs of $3,000 are allocated to each of the 3 machines on their fmvs.
§         Machine #1:
$30,000 FMV           x $3,000   = $1,500
                                    60,000 total price
                        Basis = $31,500
 
–          Apportionment Based on Relative Usage
o       Must determine basis when convert property from personal use to business. 
o       Basis for computing depreciation is the lower of
§         Fmv
§         Adjusted basis of the property at the time the asset is transferred from personal use to an income-producing use or for use in a trade or business